Half-Penny Thoughts — 21aug26

Whether in relation to my own writing or to others’ writing, I am often surprised at the interpretations readers assign to the pieces in their comments.

In those moments, I cock my head off to the side like a confused puppy and even sometimes audibly utter, “Wot?”

That’s not to say anyone’s interpretations of anyone’s writings is wrong — because writing that invites individual interpretation is when writing is at its best. But I am trying to say that sometimes those interpretations come from a place I never imagined might exist.

Sometimes, that place in the comments is so far removed from what I imagined I wrote or read that I have to go back and see if we are referencing the same piece. And I am not always satisfied that the commentor and I are looking at the same thing, or are even in the same galaxy, let alone neighborhood.

So it goes.

My invitation to join a entirely and absolutely scientific discussion prompt for today is: Is this a wholly personal experience and am I the odd duck? Or it pretty much the norm from your experience? Bonus points: Do you disagree with my earlier statement, “Writing that invites individual interpretation is when writing is at its best”? Agree?

Please Note: Right now, the US is phasing out pennies in favor of nickels as the base measure of the dollar — “What could possibly go wrong with that idea?” they asked after declaring the penny ‘cancelled’; no more $1.99 deals, I expect — so you’ll need at least ten thoughts before that threshold is crossed.


19 responses to “Half-Penny Thoughts — 21aug26”

  1. Chico’s Mom Avatar

    Agree.

    Each person brings their on personality and life experiences to the table. Something that I find funny; someone else might find offensive.

    Personally, my mind is like a dog in a tornado. The ball that just went sailing past me in the funnel, I’m going to chase that. Often ignoring the bigger picture. Aka the tornado.

    1. michael raven Avatar

      I’m likely to be one of those people who’s sense of humor offends. It’s not intentional, I just find things funny that make other people look at me oddly.

      1. Chico’s Mom Avatar

        Understood.

        I’m still chasing that ball. Oh look, a door. Let’s surf the tornado.

        If we take whatever experience the reader brings to the table out of the equation, then what’s the point? We have written something solely for our own purposes.

        1. michael raven Avatar

          One day, I will find readers!

          A definite maybe! Assuredly!

          …Oh, who am I trying to kid?

          1. Chico’s Mom Avatar

            Your writing is fantastic. And you will.

          2. michael raven Avatar

            It needs improvement. Eventually, I write pretty one day 🙂

  2. sopantooth Avatar

    I don’t get enough comments to have much of a sample size but I’m familiar with this phenomenon. I’d say about half is just people coming at things from different perspectives and half is they didn’t really read it that closely. With an unknown margin of error for me not being good at communicating what I think I’m communicating.

    1. michael raven Avatar

      It’s even visiting other people’s blogs.

      I might not know the author’s true intent but I’m frequently puzzled by the comments several of them receive on their posts. But you probably have the gist of it and your proportions seem legit.

      There is always the likelihood that I’m completely bonkers and I’m the odd duck in the equation.

  3. eob2 Avatar

    Some poems are definitive and there is no need to read it in any other way. However poems that use metaphorical expressions are more despicable to interpretation.

    1. eob2 Avatar

      *more susceptible

      1. michael raven Avatar

        😉 Jimmy the drunk gnome is at the autocorrect helm again. He always seems to have his shift when I’m writing.

    2. michael raven Avatar

      True. I think a larger majority of poems are like that: pretty straightforward. That’s why it makes me scratch my head when people take those more “clean” pieces and go way off in left field with the interpretation. I have to read it again, thinking I missed something that the author intended and, welp, still not seeing the connection the reader makes.

      Thanks for your comments tonight. I enjoy seeing your presence around more lately.

      1. eob2 Avatar

        Thanks you and you’re welcome.

  4. eob2 Avatar

    PS I find that with some of your writing sometimes gives me pause as to what is he really saying here. 🤨

    1. michael raven Avatar

      I’ll take that as a compliment and a sign I’m going in the right direction. Thank you. 🙏💙

  5. chrisnelson61 Avatar

    I like writing that makes me sit up and go ‘hmm’, or, indeed, that stirs something in me. And yes, I’m in agreement that personal interpretation is important and can wander far from the writer’s original intent. Does that necessarily matter? Perhaps not as to stimulate thought should be the aim (imho).
    Whilst not inundated with comments I have had my fair share of ‘I like how you’ve interpreted this’, ‘you’ve missed the point’, and ‘have you read this?’ comments. And even the odd ‘yes, I’ve got my idea across’ moments, so you’re not the only duck in the shooting gallery!
    Really, cancelling pennies? So how does Maths work in schools, then? ‘Today we’re learning about money. There are 100 cents in a dollar, because cent is Latin for 100. Except we don’t have cents so now we are counting groups of five cents to each dollar which are called nickels. So how many nickels do we need to make a dollar?’ Confused faces all round!
    I’m old enough to remember Imperial measures over here: 12 pennies in a shilling, 20 shillings in a pound, 21 in a guinea. Tough, but made for good mathematicians!

  6. michael raven Avatar

    I think personal interpretation of writing is essential. But wow! Some of those interpretations are not even close to what I read.

    Reading some of the comments on your site, I’ve had those “have you read this?” moments. Something said relatively recent on your site contributed to my writing this post, as well as a few other regular places I visit.

    Yes, they cancelled pennies. And now are going to be issuing some absurd rounding rules for how to handle nickel fractions because they quit making pennies. Just more intellectual poverty and unintended consequences because no one really bothered to think about something before they declared it to be cancelled. Peak absurdity over on this side of the pond.

    One of these days I’ll have to actually understand how Imperial measures were concocted. It always has felt completely arbitrary. 12 inches to the foot and 16 ounces to a pint, two pints to the quart, four quarts to a gallon (finally, one that makes sense!) and so forth. Even more mysterious is that Americans refuse to adopt metric.

    Wait.. we didn’t decide to do it first, so it makes perfect sense 🙄

  7. shredbobted Avatar

    Sometimes what I think is important and what the audience thinks is important are two different things, and i get a sense of that. I think it’s an important part of this medium.

    1. michael raven Avatar

      It’s part of it, certainly. But I’m regularly surprised at where people take things.

Leave a comment. Markdown permitted.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.